I’d like both, but if I have to pick one I’ll take the one with offers from Cincinnati, New Mexico, Dayton, Drexel, Kent State, Temple, George Mason, Robert Morris, ODU, USF, Evansville, Rhode Island, VCU, Penn State, Temple, Ohio, ETSU, Akron, and Marshall; who happens to be a position of need in a couple of years. I figure those coaching staffs know more about D1 talent than I do.
The other one, while he passes the eye test, appears to only have a conditional offer from Marshall at this point.
Like I said, i’d prefer to have both but the above info is factual. There is no question of which is considered the better recruit at this moment in time.