A message board is for these type of discussions. I have a different take without any sources or knowledge.
What if it is a combination of all of this. Huff may have wanted out but over time decided he liked it at Marshall. He reports to Smith not Spears is my understanding (could be wrong) and sees what Smith has going on at MU and sees the growth and it changed his mind. He sees he was able to get talent to MU (several new studs on this team) and win a championship. His wife may have quit St Joe because she just wanted to spend more time with her young family.
This all could be posturing as he has a big time agent and after this weekend he secured a nice contract and raise for himself and his assistants.
I hope he stays.
Consensus seems to be a combination.
A lot of people seem to really believe the wife thing. And many believe there was real tension between Spears and Huff.
I just think cooler heads could have prevailed. At the time of last year, I completely understand we would have low-balled Huff with a new deal. But as the team was coalescing this year after the Georgia Southern game, egos should have been put aside and real conversations should have been made.
It's not just about Huff and the singular performance of the team. It's also about continuity and the clean program he has provided. That should have been taken more seriously than allow the friction between the athletic director and the head coach to fester.
And if the president knew this, he should have taken action. But now here we stand.